Old First Staff

Old First Staff

Our Devoted Leaders
The Rev. Michael W. Caine
The Rev. Michael W. Caine
Church Pastor
Opening doors to welcome everyone to our church family
Rev. Geneva Butz
Rev. Geneva Butz
Pastor Emerita
Old First’s first female pastor
Holly Phares
Holly Phares
Artist in Residence
Artistry can change the way we see the world
Teresa
Teresa
Church Administrator
Keeping everyone on track.
John Owens
Outreach Assistant
A smile is the simplest way to spread happiness
Alesha Thomas
Alesha Thomas
Outreach Coordinator
Creating a kind world through beautiful neighborhoods
Sharing the Love of God

About Our Church Leaders


We dedicate ourselves to being friends and allies for our members. We are always happy to make something great happen for you.

We are blessed to have such talented and driven members of our congregation leading us in walking with Christ